What was staged, and the studies
More, liked less
What the room did
TRUE Later the room asked how much you like your stone.
STAGED Half of visitors, picked at random, get the stone alone. The other half get the same stone with two broken pieces beside it: strictly more, and expected to be liked less.
The study
- Hsee (1998), “Less is better”, Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. doi:10.1002/(SICI)1099-0771(199806)11:2<107::AID-BDM292>3.0.CO;2-Y
Has it held up
Robust. Replicated in Many Labs 2: d = 0.78, N = 7,646, on the original wording. The room's version is new and may show nothing.
The original result belongs to the original wording and setting. What the room does is an adaptation, and it may show nothing.
What happened here
The totals open when 100 people have sat in the room on the record. Until then there is no number to show, and none is made up.
Citations and replication notes last checked 2026-11-19. “Not checked” means no replication evidence was read, not that none exists.