What was staged, and the studies
“That's the one we'd have chosen.”
What the room did
TRUE After you picked a light, the room said it would have picked the same one.
STAGED It says that to everyone, about every light.
The study
- Burger, Messian, Patel, del Prado et al. (2004), Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. doi:10.1177/0146167203258838
Has it held up
Mixed. Four studies found that a shared birthday, first name or fingerprint type raised compliance, and found no effect when the shared feature was common. Undergraduate samples; no replication was read. The room's version is the weak form.
The original result belongs to the original wording and setting. What the room does is an adaptation, and it may show nothing.
Citations and replication notes last checked 2026-11-19. “Not checked” means no replication evidence was read, not that none exists.