What was staged, and the studies
A notice that feels safe
What the room did
TRUE The card arrived after the first breath, in the room's own voice and type, and offered a real choice. Everything on it was true. Its timing and its tone were chosen because they make people more willing to agree.
The studies
- John, Acquisti & Loewenstein (2011), Journal of Consumer Research. doi:10.1086/656423
- Brandimarte, Acquisti & Loewenstein (2012), Social Psychological and Personality Science. doi:10.1177/1948550612455931
Has it held up
Not checked. Each paper reports its own experiments: disclosure follows cues that have little to do with real hazard, and more control over release makes people disclose more. No replication of either was read.
The original result belongs to the original wording and setting. What the room does is an adaptation, and it may show nothing.
Citations and replication notes last checked 2026-11-19. “Not checked” means no replication evidence was read, not that none exists.